16.1.6 Lab – Hashing Things Out Answers version
- Part 1: Hashing a Text File with OpenSSL
- Part 2: Verifying Hashes
Background / Scenario
Hash functions are mathematical algorithms designed to take data as input and generate a fixed-size, unique string of characters, also known as the hash. Designed to be fast, hash functions are very hard to reverse; it is very hard to recover the data that created any given hash, based on the hash alone. Another important property of hash function is that even the smallest change done to the input data yields a completely different hash.
While OpenSSL can be used to generate and compare hashes, other tools are available. Some of these tools are also included in this lab.
- Security Workstation virtual machine
Part 1: Hashing a Text File with OpenSSL
OpenSSL can be used as a standalone tool for hashing. To create a hash of a text file, follow the steps below:
a. Start the Security Workstation VM and log in with username sec_admin and password net_secPW.
b. In the Security Workstation virtual machine, open a terminal window.
c. Because the text file to hash is in the /home/sec_admin/lab.support.files/ directory, change to that directory:
[[email protected] ~]$ cd /home/sec_admin/lab.support.files/
d. Type the command below to list the contents of the
letter_to_grandma.txt text file on the screen:
[[email protected] lab.support.files]$ cat letter_to_grandma.txt Hi Grandma, I am writing this letter to thank you for the chocolate chip cookies you sent me. I got them this morning and I have already eaten half of the box! They are absolutely delicious! I wish you all the best. Love, Your cookie-eater grandchild.
e. From the terminal window, issue the command below to hash the text file. The command will use SHA-2-256 as the hashing algorithm to generate a hash of the text file. The hash will be displayed on the screen after OpenSSL has computed it.
[[email protected] lab.support.files]$ openssl sha256 letter_to_grandma.txt SHA256(letter_to_grandma.txt)= deff9c9bbece44866796ff6cf21f2612fbb77aa1b2515a900bafb29be118080b
Notice the format of the output. OpenSSL displays the hashing algorithm used, SHA-256, followed by the name of file used as input data. The SHA-256 hash itself is displayed after the equal (‘=’) sign.
f. Hash functions are useful for verifying the integrity of the data regardless of whether it is an image, a song, or a simple text file. The smallest change results in a completely different hash. Hashes can be calculated before and after transmission, and then compared. If the hashes do not match, then data was modified during transmission.
Let’s modify the letter_to_grandma.txt text file and recalculate the MD5 hash. Issue the command below to open nano, a command-line text editor.
[[email protected] lab.support.files]$ nano letter_to_grandma.txt
Using nano, change the first sentence from ‘Hi Grandma’ to ‘Hi Grandpa’. Notice we are changing only one character, ‘m’ to ‘p’. After the change has been made, press the <CONTROL+X> keys to save the modified file. Press ‘Y’ to confirm the name and save the file. Press the <Enter> key and you will exit out of nano to continue onto the next step.
g. Now that the file has been modified and saved, run the same command again to generate a SHA-2-256 hash of the file.
[[email protected] lab.support.files]$ openssl sha256 letter_to_grandma.txt SHA256(letter_to_grandma.txt)= 43302c4500b7c4b8e574ba27a59d83267812493c029fd054c9242f3ac73100bc
Is the new hash different that hash calculated in item (d)? How different?
Yes. The new hash is completely different than the previous hash.
h. A hashing algorithm with longer bit-length, such as SHA-2-512, can also be used. To generate a SHA-2-512 hash of the letter_to_grandma.txt file, use the command below:
[[email protected] lab.support.files]$ openssl sha512 letter_to_grandma.txt SHA512(letter_to_grandma.txt)= 7c35db79a06aa30ae0f6de33f2322fd419560ee9af9cedeb6e251f2f1c4e99e0bbe5d2fc32ce5 01468891150e3be7e288e3e568450812980c9f8288e3103a1d3 [[email protected] lab.support.files]$
sha512sum to generate SHA-2-256 and SHA-2-512 hash of the
[[email protected] lab.support.files]$ sha256sum letter_to_grandma.txt 43302c4500b7c4b8e574ba27a59d83267812493c029fd054c9242f3ac73100bc letter_to_grandma.txt [[email protected] lab.support.files]$ sha512sum letter_to_grandma.txt 7c35db79a06aa30ae0f6de33f2322fd419560ee9af9cedeb6e251f2f1c4e99e0bbe5d2fc32ce5 01468891150e3be7e288e3e568450812980c9f8288e3103a1d3 letter_to_grandma.txt
Do the hashes generated with
sha512sum match the hashes generated in items (f) and (g), respectively? Explain.
Yes. While different tools are used, they use the same hashing algorithm and input data.
Note: SHA-2 is the recommended standard for hashing. While SHA-2 has not yet been effectively compromised, computers are becoming more and more powerful. It is expected that this natural evolution will soon make it possible for attackers to break SHA-2.
SHA-3 is the newest hashing algorithm and eventually be the replacement for SHA-2 family of hashes.
Note: The Security Workstation VM only includes support for SHA-2-224, SHA-2-256, and SHA-2-512 (sha224sum, sha256sum, and sha512sum, respectively).
Part 2: Verifying Hashes
As mentioned before, a common use for hashes is to verify file integrity. Follow the steps below to use SHA-2-256 hashes to verify the integrity of sample.img, a file downloaded from the Internet.
a. Along with sample.img, sample.img_SHA256.sig was also downloaded. sample.img_SHA256.sig is a file containing the SHA-2-256 hash that was computed by the website. First, use the cat command to display the contents of the sample.img_SHA256.sig file:
[[email protected] lab.support.files]$ cat sample.img_SHA256.sig c56c4724c26eb0157963c0d62b76422116be31804a39c82fd44ddf0ca5013e6a
b. Use SHA256sum to calculate the SHA-2-256 hash of the sample.img file:
[[email protected] lab.support.files]$ sha256sum sample.img c56c4724c26eb0157963c0d62b76422116be31804a39c82fd44ddf0ca5013e6a sample.img
Was the sample.img downloaded without errors? Explain.
Yes. Because both hashes match, the hash calculated before download and the one calculated after, it is correct to state that no errors were introduced during download.
Note: While comparing hashes is a relatively robust method to detect transmission errors, there are better ways to ensure the file has not been tampered with. Tools, such as gpg, provide a much better method for ensuring the downloaded file has not been modified by third parties and is in fact the file the publisher meant to publish.